Back to blog

How to Build a Strong Email Reputation and Escape the Spam Folder

Does it seem like your newsletter gets sent straight to the spam folder, never reaching the people you want it to? 

You're not alone. An astonishing 45.37% of all daily emails end up in spam folders. 

But here’s the good news. By understanding email reputation and taking a few simple steps, you can ensure your newsletters land right where they belong: in your readers' inboxes.

What is Email Reputation? Why is It Important? 

Just like you, email providers have a reputation to uphold. They want to deliver valuable content to their users, not spam. 

This is where email reputation, also known as domain reputation or sender score, comes in. It's a trust rating assigned by email providers (like Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) to your email address or domain. It reflects how safe and reliable you are as a sender.

Think of it like a credit score for email. A high score indicates you're a trustworthy sender of valuable content, while a low score suggests you might be a spammer.

What Factors Affect Email Reputation? 

Several things influence your email reputation, including:

  • Subscriber Engagement

Opens, clicks, unsubscribes, and spam complaints all play a role. Engaged subscribers who consistently interact with your content signal to email providers that you're a sender of value.

Learn how to create an email newsletter that stands out in your reader's inbox.

  • Sending Frequency and Consistency

Regularly sending high-quality content builds trust. Bombarding subscribers with sporadic blasts can raise red flags.

  • Domain and IP Address Reputation

A clean history is essential. Avoid sharing your sending domain or IP with untrustworthy senders, as their poor reputation can taint yours.

  • Email List Hygiene

Regularly removing inactive subscribers demonstrates you maintain a healthy list and reduces the risk of sending to invalid addresses, which can negatively impact your score.

How to Build a Strong Email Reputation?

While building a strong email reputation takes some effort, the good news is that a low score isn't a permanent roadblock. 

Here are some key practices to help you improve your email reputation and ensure your newsletters are delivered to your most engaged subscribers:

  • Grow Your List Organically

Avoid buying email lists. Focus on attracting subscribers who genuinely want your content. Offer valuable opt-in incentives like exclusive content or discounts.

  • Use Double Opt-In 

This confirmation step verifies subscribers truly want to hear from you and reduces the risk of spam traps (email addresses used solely to catch spammers).

  • Maintain a Clean List

Regularly remove inactive subscribers and those with invalid addresses. Why waste resources sending to people who aren't interested?

  • Focus on Subscriber Value

This is the heart of the recipe! Provide engaging content that keeps readers interested. Personalize your content whenever possible to cater to different interests and needs.

  • Segment Your Audience

Tailor content to different subscriber interests for better engagement. This not only improves the reading experience but also encourages clicks and interactions, boosting your sender score.

  • Authenticate Your Domain

Sender Policy Framework (SPF), DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM), Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance (DMARC) protocols verify your identity and prevent spoofing (when someone sends emails pretending to be you). This adds a layer of trust for email providers.

Learn how to correctly set up your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records.

  • Schedule Emails Consistently

Don't bombard subscribers, but establish a regular sending pattern. This predictability helps improve open rates and overall engagement.

  • Monitor Your Analytics

Track key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and unsubscribe rates to identify areas for improvement. Analyze what content resonates with your audience and adjust your strategy accordingly.

Common Mistakes to Avoid: Don't Let These Spoil Your Email Reputation

Just like a delicious recipe can be ruined by a single wrong ingredient, here are some common mistakes that can damage your newsletter reputation:

  • Sending Unsolicited Emails

Only send newsletters to those who have opted-in. Respecting subscriber privacy is paramount.

  • Low-Quality Content

Subscribers will disengage and potentially mark your emails as spam. Focus on providing valuable, informative, or entertaining content that resonates with your audience.

  • Too Many Emails

Sending too frequently can overwhelm subscribers and lead to unsubscribes. Find a sending frequency that works for your audience and stick to it.

  • Typos and Errors

Professionalism matters. Proofread your newsletters carefully before hitting send. Sloppy mistakes can erode trust and damage your reputation.

Maintaining a Strong Reputation: A Long-Term Commitment

Building a strong newsletter reputation is an ongoing process. Here are some tips for long-term success:

  • Regularly review your email statistics

Track performance and identify areas for improvement. Use this data to refine your content strategy and sending schedule.

  • Clean your list regularly

Remove inactive subscribers and invalid addresses. A clean list ensures your content reaches the right people.

  • Use a reputable email marketing platform

Many email newsletter platforms offer features to help manage reputation, such as email verification tools, analytics dashboards, and spam checker functionalities.

Land in Inboxes, Not Spam Folders – Try Letterhead

Building a strong newsletter reputation takes time and effort, but the rewards are significant. By following these tips, you can ensure your newsletter never languishes in the spam folder.

Unsure where to start? Schedule a free consultation with our experts to see how we can help you optimize your sender score and get your newsletter delivered – every time.

Let's Talk